Because clarity without kindness is cruelty, and kindness without clarity is chaos.
By Caleb Anderson | Leadership Coach & Founder, The Leader Club
Most leaders don’t avoid hard feedback because they don’t care. They avoid it because they do.
They don’t want to hurt someone. They don’t want to damage trust. They don’t want to blow up morale.
So they soften it. Delay it. Dance around it.
And unintentionally, they make things worse.
Here’s the paradox of leadership:
Kind leaders are often the most direct.
But they’re direct without being demeaning. They’re clear without being cruel. And honest without losing humanity.
Here’s how to do that well.
1. Refresh Your Perspective First
Before you say a word, zoom out.
Ask yourself: Is the world ending? Are lives at risk? Is this problem solvable?
In almost every business situation, the answer is yes, it’s solvable.
That doesn’t mean the issue isn’t serious. It means you don’t need panic-energy to fix it.
Urgency is helpful. Intensity can be helpful. Perspective is essential.
When you calm your nervous system first, you’re far more likely to speak with strength instead of sharpness.
2. Model Ownership, Before You Expect It
If you want a culture of accountability, it starts with you.
You hired the person. You set (or failed to set) the expectations. You allowed patterns to continue.
That doesn’t mean you take the blame for everything. It means you own your part first.
Try this:
“I want to start by owning my side of this. I didn’t set this up clearly enough, and that’s on me.”
This immediately lowers defenses.
It tells the other person: This is a partnership, not a trial.
Leaders who model ownership create teams that do the same.
3. Separate the Person from the Problem
This is one of the most important leadership distinctions there is.
The person is not the problem.
The problem is the problem.
(Unless you already know you’re dealing with the wrong person in the wrong seat, in which case, that’s a different conversation.)
When giving feedback, be on the person’s side while you attack the issue together.
Say things like:
- “I believe in you, and we need to address this.”
- “I want you to succeed here. That’s why this matters.”
- “Let’s look at the problem objectively and figure out the fix.”
This keeps the conversation collaborative instead of adversarial.
People will fight for solutions when they don’t feel like they’re fighting for their worth.
4. Be Direct, Not Demeaning
Here’s a truth most leaders don’t want to hear:
Avoiding direct feedback is not kind. It’s unfair.
When you gloss over issues, beat around the bush, or hope things resolve on their own, you’re delaying clarity, and clarity is a form of respect.
But direct does not mean harsh.
You can say:
“This outcome isn’t acceptable.”
Without saying:
“You’re not good enough.”
You can address behavior, results, and expectations without attacking character, intelligence, or intent.
Once feedback turns personal, the brain goes into defense mode, and learning stops.
Your job isn’t to win the moment. It’s to change the outcome.
5. Vent Your Anger Before the Conversation, Not During It
Anger feels powerful. But it’s unreliable.
Intensity works. Urgency works. Passion works.
Anger, unchecked, does not work.
If you’re feeling heated, don’t bring that into the room.
Vent privately. Go for a walk. Journal. Talk it out with a coach or trusted peer.
Then come back regulated, grounded, and clear.
You will always say something you regret when you’re dysregulated.
And once words land, you don’t get them back. Hard conversations require strength, not emotional leakage.
Final Thought: Kindness Is Not Softness
Being kind doesn’t mean lowering standards. It means raising clarity without lowering dignity.
The leaders people trust most are the ones who:
- Tell the truth
- Stay composed
- Take ownership
- Separate people from problems
- And care enough to have the conversation at all
If you do that consistently, something powerful happens:
Feedback stops feeling like an attack and starts feeling like leadership.
That’s when performance improves. That’s when trust deepens. That’s when teams grow.
And that’s what great leadership actually looks like.
🧭 If you want to build a culture where feedback is clear, calm, and productive, this is exactly the kind of leadership work we do inside The Leader Club.
We teach the 10 leadership skills that matter in a community of other inspiring leaders.
👉 Sign up for our free LIVE masterclass that explains our unique system (built to enhance your existing execution system, especially if you use EOS).
Register for the FREE masterclass here: https://go.theleaderclub.com/eos-webinar
